Investing in Productive Finance

Online in Zoom

Thursday 2nd November 2023

13:00 – 17:20 GMT

Turning Pensions Policy into Practice

Having erred on the side of conservatism for the last two decades, official pensions policy now distinctly favours encouraging pensions trustees to invest more heavily in productive assets, which means assuming more investment risk especially in long-term strategies.

This is certainly the mood music that is playing at the DWP, at TPR and at the Treasury, in the shape of the Mansion House Reforms. While many LGPS funds have been strongly invested in growth assets for some time, the same is not true for DC and private DB funds which have subject to significant investment constraints, both regulatory and competition-driven. 

Delegates to the Masterclass will examine whether this new policy approach can genuinely deliver better pensions outcomes and create exciting investment opportunities, and debate the governance, investment and management practices that will be needed to achieve these. 

In common with all the SGPE Masterclasses, the event will be highly interactive, with free and frank exchanges of views, and participants are encouraged to engage and contribute proactively throughout.  

Chair

Mike Weston

Chair of Trustees
Institute of Cancer
Research Scheme

Keynote Speaker

Louise Davey

Interim Director of Regulatory Policy, Analysis & Advice
The Pensions Regulator

Agenda
Devil's Advocates

Rachel Brougham, Trustee Executive, BESTrustees
Mike Clark, Founder Director, Ario Advisory
Silvia Knott-Martin, Client Relations Manager, London CIV

A panel of Devil’s Advocates will be on duty for the course of the afternoon.

They will be available to pose challenging questions to any of the conference speakers when invited to do so by the Moderator of each session. They will provide an end of day summary of the main learning and action points from the conference.

13.00 – 13.15
Meet & Greet
13.15 – 13.30
Welcome & Introduction

Masterclass Chair:
Mike Weston
Pension Scheme Chair of Trustees
Institute for Cancer Research 

Programme Director:
Stephen Glover
Director
SG Pensions Enterprise

13.30 – 14.00
Keynote Address: The New Regulatory Regime

Louise Davey
Interim Director of Regulatory Policy, Analysis & Advice
The Pensions Regulator

Our speaker will outline how the Pensions Regulator proposes to encourage a new environment of greater investment opportunity across the pensions industry, with reference to three key building blocks for better practice; sophisticated investment governance, greater industry consolidation and an increased number of highly qualified trustees driving performance.

They will discuss how a new Value-for-Money framework for DC and a new DB Funding Code will clarify how investors in both these sectors will be enabled to invest more productively in growth assets.

There will be an opportunity for extensive Q&A with the audience.

14.00 – 14.40
Panel Discussion: The Trade-Off Between Productive Capital & Fiduciary Duty

Moderator:
Mike Weston
Pensions Scheme Chair of Trustees
Institute for Cancer Research

John Chilman
Chief Executive Officer
Railpen

Debbie Fielder
Deputy Head
Clwyd Pension Fund

James Livingston
Partner
Foresight Group

Chris Pond
Chair
Financial Inclusion Commission
Former Labour Pensions Minister

A large part of the government’s agenda is designed to stimulate the UK economy by encouraging pension funds to invest more heavily in domestic productive assets.

Fiduciary duty obliges trustees to seek the best performing investments, subject to risk tolerance, wherever these may be found. So are these two objectives the same?

An expert panel will debate this proposition with reference to the expected return outlook for several key investment opportunities, especially in UK private markets, and their suitability for inclusion in pensions portfolios.

14.40 – 15.10
Presentations: A Spotlight on Productive Finance Opportunities

Moderator:
Mike Weston
Pension Scheme Chair of Trustees
Institute for Cancer Research

James Livingston
Partner
Foresight Group

Jonny Potter
Interim CFO
Midlands Mindforge

In this session, we will examine potential opportunities in productive finance that promise to contribute to UK economic growth while delivering attractive risk-adjusted returns to pensions’ investors. 

We will invite two private equity firms to make the case for distinct investment strategies, which they believe will satisfy these objectives: Foresight Group and Midlands Mindforge. 

Delegates will be encouraged to challenge the merits of these strategies with the presenters. 

15.10 – 15.30
Coffee at Home & Online Networking
15.30 – 16.10
Expert Discussion Groups
Group 1: Productive Finance Opportunities for DC Schemes

Facilitator:
Tegs Harding
Chair of Investment Committee
Legal & General Master Trust

Lead Discussants: 
Paul Bucksey, Chief Investment Officer, Smart Pension
Julius Pursaill, Strategic Adviser, Cushon
Claire Felgate, Head of UK DC, BlackRock

Themes:

  • The new Value-for-Money framework.
  • Promoting consolidation to achieve greater scale
  • Overcoming daily dealing and charge cap constraints
  • Widening access to less liquid assets
  • Are LTAFs the answer?
  • Trends towards CDC
Group 2: Productive Finance Opportunities for the LGPS & Private DB Schemes

Facilitator:
Henry Tapper
Executive Chair
AgeWage

Lead Discussants:
Paul Brine, Trustee Director, Dalriada Trustees
Jill Davys, Director – Global Assets, Redington
Padmesh Shukla, Chief Investment Officer, TfL Pension Fund

Themes:

  • Is the government’s 10% target private markets allocation too ambitious?
  • What can be done to keep corporate DB schemes open to investment in productive finance?
  • Can insurers offering annuities claim to be providing productive finance?
  • Is there a liquidity crunch within the LGPS and if so – where and why?
  • Can small DB schemes realistically get the deals accessible to larger schemes?
  • From what we have heard of the new DB Funding Code, has productive finance become more attractive?
16.10 – 16.20
Feedback from Discussion Leaders

Tegs Harding
Chair of Investment Committee
Legal & General Master Trust

Henry Tapper
Executive Chair
AgeWage

The Facilitators will report back on the main points covered and the salient conclusions reached in their respective discussion groups.

16.20 – 17.00
Panel Discussion: The New Road Ahead

Moderator:
Karen Shackleton
Chair & Founder
Pensions for Purpose

Steve Bates
Chief Executive Officer
UK BioIndustry Association

George Graham
Director
South Yorkshire Pension Authority

Ian MacRae
Finance Pensions Investment Manager
Jaguar Land Rover

A panel of pensions trustees and key advisers from across the industry will discuss the practical changes they will be making to governance and investment strategies to achieve significantly higher exposure to productive assets, whether these will be sufficient to secure a step change in scheme performance, and the challenges and obstacles still to be overcome.   

17.00 – 17.10
Devil's Advocates' Summary

Rachel Brougham
Trustee Executive
BESTrustees

Mike Clark
Founder Director
Ario Advisory

Silvia Knott-Martin
Client Relations Manager
London CIV

The Devil’s Advocates will offer their summary and main takeaways from the afternoon’s proceedings.

17.10 – 17.20
Final Thoughts & Closing Remarks
Speakers

Rachel Brougham

Trustee Executive
BESTrustees

Steve Bates

Chief Executive Officer
UK BioIndustry Assn.

Paul Brine

Trustee Director
Dalriada Trustees

Paul Bucksey

Chief Investment Officer
Smart Pension

John Chilman

Chief Executive Officer
Railpen

Mike Clark

Founder Director
Ario Advisory

Jill Davys

Director – Global Assets
Redington

Claire Felgate

MD – Consultant Relations
BlackRock

Debbie Fielder

Deputy Head
Clwyd Pension Fund

George Graham

Director
South Yorkshire Pension Authority

Tegs Harding

Investment Committee
L&G Master Trust

Silvia Knott-Martin

Client Relations Manager
London CIV

James Livingston

Partner
Foresight Group

Chris Pond

Chair
Financial Inclusion Commission

Julius Pursaill

Strategic Adviser
Cushon

Padmesh Shukla

Chief Investment Officer
TfL Pension Fund

Karen Shackleton

Chair & Founder

Pensions for Purpose

Henry Tapper

Executive Chair

AgeWage

Sponsors
Click on images for more information
Scroll to Top

Mike Weston

Chief Executive Officer
LGPS Central Ltd.

Mike was appointed Chief Executive Officer of LGPS Central Ltd. in March 2019. He was previously Chief Executive of the Pensions Infrastructure Platform (PiP). Mike had been Chief Investment Officer for the DMGT pension schemes and worked as an Investment Director in the City managing institutional equity portfolios at asset management firms such as Hermes and Merrill Lynch Investment Managers.

In 2013, Mike was appointed as an Independent Trustee of the Institute of Cancer Research Pension Scheme. He has also served as a Non-Executive Director of the NAPF and as Vice Chair of its Defined Benefit Council.

Mike holds an MBA from Cranfield School of Management and graduated from Cambridge University with an MA in Natural Sciences.

Rachel Brougham

Trustee Executive
BESTrustees

Rachel Brougham has worked in the pensions industry for more than 30 years. She joined BESTrustees in 2014 and currently works with a number of clients, covering both defined benefit and defined contribution schemes.

Since joining BESTrustees, Rachel’s appointments have included two master trust boards and two Independent Governance Committees of major UK pension providers, and the chairmanship of a number of defined benefit schemes. Her experience includes the development of the trustee boards, their structures and processes, including committees and appropriate reporting, and the development of robust risk management frameworks.

Rachel is used to working with and managing a number of advisers on any one scheme, expecting a collaborative and respectful working relationship between them. She is also used to working with in-house teams, ensuring that the trustee board receives the support it needs in carrying out its duties. Working with the schemes’ advisers, she has implemented TPR’s integrated risk management (IRM) approach to funding, investment and covenant work in her DB schemes to good effect, and is used to working with an overseas parent.

Rachel spent most of her career at Mercer providing actuarial, benefit, governance and DC consulting advice to clients. She remains an Associate Member of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries.

Steve Bates

Chief Executive Officer
UK BioIndustry Association

Steve Bates is the CEO of the UK Bioindustry Association, the UK’s Trade Association for innovative life science companies with over 550 members. Steve is the visible face of the vibrant UK life sciences industry to government and media. He serves on the UK Government’s Life Sciences Council and the UK Biosecurity Leadership Council.  

Steve was a founder member of the UK Government’s Vaccine Taskforce in the Covid crisis, sitting on its steering Board alongside Kate Bingham.

He is active member and former chair the International Council of Biotech Associations and has been a board member of Europabio since 2015.  

Paul Brine

Trustee Director
Dalriada Trustees

Paul Brine joined Dalriada in October 2022 as a Professional Trustee. 

He has 17 years of trustee experience, both DB and DC, and many more years with respect to risk management. Paul has worked with standalone schemes ranging from £50m to over £3bn. He has a commercial and strategic outlook to pensions and brings his industry experience to drive forward innovative solutions.

Paul’s non-trustee background is in fixed income, cash, derivative and credit markets, having spent 30 years in risk and capital markets in London and New York. 

He has chaired several boards and investment and risk management skills to benefit all boards he has served on. With his long developed financial professional skills, ranging from his risk management background to a comprehensive understanding of solvency, he works with colleagues and advisers on a peer-to-peer basis whereby two-way peer-to-peer constructive challenge always leads to better decisions, driving positive outcomes and improving the delivery of advisory services. He has an outstanding grasp of multiple asset strategies, both as trustee and practitioner, and has developed noteworthy manager monitoring processes. Paul has always focused on liquidity, and in 2020 instigated a significant structural review of a scheme’s liquidity profile “in the event that rates move significantly more than suggested”. 

Paul has a unique grasp of solvency within the trustee world, and has had sessions with risk transfer advisers so that the risk transfer team can “experience real challenge”. Paul has been publicly advocating the raising of trustee awareness of solvency issues as vital for any board considering an irrevocable risk transfer decision. He has also been approved as a Solvency II Life (Class 1) insurance company director. 

Paul holds an M.A. in Natural Sciences from St. John’s College, Cambridge.

Paul Bucksey

Chief Investment Officer
Smart pension

Paul is Chief Investment Officer at Smart Pension and is responsible for the overall strategic design and management of the Smart Pension Master Trust investment proposition, and Smart’s relationships with its fund managers. He is a member of the Trustee Investment Sub-committee, and chairs the Scheme Strategist.

Before joining Smart Pension in February 2019, Paul was a Managing Director at BlackRock (and subsequently Aegon), leading their UK defined contribution workplace pension business. During his time at BlackRock, Paul drove the development and introduction of master trust and income drawdown products, as well as enhancements to the firm’s UK target date fund range.  He has also held senior positions at Fidelity, AXA and PwC.

John Chilman

Chief Executive Officer
Railpen

John joined as Chief Executive Officer and an Executive Director of Railpen, in June 2019, having previously served for 12 years as a Director of the Railways Pension Scheme Trustee Company, and Chair for the last five years. John is also an Independent Trustee of the Nestle UK pension fund.

 John is a Chartered Accountant by qualification, and was previously Group Head of Pensions at National Grid. Prior to that John held senior financial, commercial and pension positions at a number of large companies, including Pricewaterhouse Coopers, South Western Electricity, Shell, HBOS and First Group.

Mike Clark

Founder Director
Ario Advisory

Mike runs a responsible investment advisory firm, Ario Advisory. With a background in investment management, governance, pensions and insurance, much of his work is concerned with the financial risks of climate change. He works across the investment sector with asset owners, investment managers, policymakers, regulators, investment consultants and NGOs.

Among his roles, he represents IFoA (actuaries) on the Sustainable Finance Advisory Council at the Oxford Smith School and sits on the WHEB Asset Management independent Advisory Committee. He has recently left the Brunel (LGPS) board, where he was a NED (chairing Audit&Risk, more recently Remco), and he was Specialist Adviser to the House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee for their 2018 Green Finance inquiry.

Jill Davys

Director – Global Assets
Redington

Jill is Head of LGPS at Redington, supporting LGPS funds to meet their strategic objectives by advising on strategic asset allocation, climate change and net zero, impact investing, and broader investment strategy. Redington advise a range of funds across the LGPS – led by Jill, with the support of the wider Redington LGPS team.

Having worked directly in the LGPS sector for 18 years at a senior level, Jill understands what it means to run an LGPS fund and the challenges they face. She regularly contributes to events, conferences, and roundtables, and is a strong advocatefor responsible investing for delivering both sustainability and impact alongside the financial returns required to pay pensions.

Previously, Jill worked as a fund manager for over 20 years. Her primary focus was on equities, but she was also involved in strategic asset allocation and derivatives.

Claire Felgate

Managing Director, UK & MEA Global Consultant Relations
Blackrock

Claire Felgate leads Blackrock’s strategic engagement and drives execution with consultant firms across the UK, Middle East and Africa regions. Her leadership encompasses both advisory and delegated, with key focus areas in defined contribution (DC), Local Consultants and Field Consultants. She partners closely across BlackRock’s client businesses, including the Institutional Client Business, Wealth and Family Offices, Endowments and Foundations and collaborates with investment colleagues across the firm to deliver the best outcomes for our clients.

Claire brings a wealth of experience with clients and consultants and a deep understanding of DC from her previous roles as Head of UK DC and as a relationship manager for a number of key DB clients.

Claire’s service at the firm dates back to 2011. Prior to joining BlackRock, Claire was a Relationship Manager at UBS Global Asset Management where she worked with a number of key institutional clients, with a strong focus on Real Estate. Claire started her career as an Analyst at Goldman Sachs.

Claire earned a BBusSci (Hons) degree in Marketing and Finance from the University of Cape Town. Claire holds the Investment Management Certificate and is also a CFA Charterholder.

Debbie Fielder

Deputy Head
Clwyd Pension Fund

Debbie is the Deputy Head of the Clwyd Pension Fund, a £2.4bn Local Government Pension Scheme and a member of the Wales Pension Partnership (WPP).  

She represents The Clwyd Fund on both Private Markets and Responsible Investment working groups within the WPP and represents the WPP on the Responsible Investment Cross Pool Group and also the Scheme Advisory Board Responsible Investment Advisory Group. 

The Clwyd Fund has investments with many Private Market managers and Debbie is a member on several of those investments Advisory Boards. 

Debbie has also recently been appointed as a Non-Executive Director for Pensions For Purpose. 

In her spare time, Debbie enjoys taking her dogs and grandchildren away camping and caravanning.

George Graham

Fund Director
South Yorkshire Pensions Authority

George joined the South Yorkshire Pensions Authority as Fund Director in February 2018. As Head of Paid Service is responsible for the management of all aspects of the Authority’s activity.

Previously, he was Managing Director of LPP’s pension administration business, having led the Lancashire County Pension Fund prior to the transfer of its staff to LPP as part of the creation of the joint venture with the London Pension Fund Authority. A fellow of CIPFA, George’s previous career in local government finance involved roles as Deputy County Treasurer at Lancashire County Council, Director of Resources at Rossendale BC and Director of Finance at Chorley BC. These were preceded by roles at Northamptonshire CC and Oxfordshire CC, where he did his CIPFA training.

George also represents practitioners on the Local Government Pension Scheme Advisory Board for England & Wales, and is a member of the Board’s Responsible Investment Advisory Group.

Silvia Knott-Martin

Client Relations Manager
London CIV

Silvia Knott-Martin joined the London CIV in October 2019 and brings with her 20 years of industry experience serving institutional pension investors in the UK, Continental Europe, and North America.
In her previous roles, Silvia has gained extensive experience as client portfolio manager, relationship manager and product specialist working for a number of global asset managers. At the London CIV, her role involves supporting the London LGPS in implementing their investment strategies to progress their pooling agenda.

James Livingston

Partner
Foresight Group

James joined Foresight in 2007 and currently works as a Partner in the London office. He has over 15 years’ experience. James is responsible for originating, negotiating and managing growth and buyout investments in a variety of sectors, as well as supporting the wider team.

Prior to Foresight, James worked at Deloitte as a Strategy Consultant where he advised businesses in the healthcare and technology sectors. He has also been a professional athlete, rowing for Great Britain and winning a silver medal at the 2003 Rowing World Championships.

James holds an MA in Natural Sciences and Management Studies from Cambridge University as well as the CIMA Advanced Diploma in Management Accounting.

Chris Pond

Chair
Financial Inclusion Commission

Chris is a former Pensions Minister, who now serves as Chair of the Financial Inclusion Commission, of the Lending Standards Board, of the Equity Release Council Standards Board and of The Money Charity. He is an Independent Director of the Current Account Switch Service (Pay.UK) and of Cape Claims Services, and is a trustee of GambleAware and the Money and Mental Health Policy Institute.

Chris is a member of the Treasury FinTech Delivery Panel. He has been Chief Executive of two national charities and chair or trustee of many others and was formerly Director of Financial Capability and Head of Consumer Affairs of the Financial Services Authority.

Julius Pursaill

Independent Expert
Pensions Adviser

Julius spent his executive career working with DC pensions in both the insurance and asset management industries. In his subsequent non-executive career, Julius has held a number of independent pension and investment governance roles. He was one of the founding trustee directors of NEST Corporation and chaired both its investment and risk committees.

Karen Shackleton

Founder & Director
Pensions for Purpose

Karen has worked in the finance sector for over 30 years. As well as being Founder of Pensions for Purpose, she is Deputy Chair of the Strategic Investment Board for the Ministry of Justice and a non-executive director and Chair of the Board of Resonance Ltd, a social impact investment company. She sits on the Advisory Council of the Impact Investing Institute.

Karen also provides independent investment advice to the London Boroughs of Islington, Camden and Hounslow through MJ Hudson. She was the Chief Executive/Managing Director of Allenbridge Epic Investment Advisers from 2010 to 2013. Prior to that, she had ten years’ experience as a fund manager and director for County NatWest and BZW Investment Management (now BlackRock).

Henry Tapper

Founder & CEO
AgeWage

Henry is the founder of both AgeWage and the Pension PlayPen, designed to map the pensions genome and ensure everyone gets data driven information on value for money. He has worked most of his career in pensions, most recently as a Director of First Actuarial, and notably at Eagle Star and Zurich Assurance.

He is a well known blogger on all pensions-related issues at henrytapper.com.

Blackrock’s purpose is to help more and more people experience financial well-being. As a fiduciary to investors and a leading provider of financial technology, we help millions of people build savings that serve them throughout their lives by making investing easier and more affordable.

CONTACT

Zahaib Hussain
Relationship Manager – UK Institutional DC Business

For more information, visit Blackrock’s website here.

Foresight Group was founded in 1984 and is a leading listed infrastructure and private equity investment manager. With a long-established focus on ESG and sustainability-led strategies, it aims to provide attractive returns to its institutional and private investors from hard-to-access private markets.  

Foresight manages over 400 infrastructure assets with a focus on solar and onshore wind assets, bioenergy and waste, as well as renewable energy enabling projects, energy efficiency management solutions, social and core infrastructure projects and sustainable forestry assets. Its private equity team manages eleven regionally focused investment funds across the UK and an SME impact fund supporting Irish SMEs. This team reviews over 2,500 business plans each year and currently supports more than 250 investments in SMEs. Foresight Capital Management manages four strategies across seven investment vehicles.  

Foresight operates in eight countries across Europe, Australia and United States with AUM of £12.1 billion (based on unaudited AUM as at 30 September 2023). Foresight Group Holdings Limited listed on the Main Market of the London Stock Exchange in February 2021 and is a constituent of the FTSE250 index. 

CONTACT

Emma Hardcastle
Associate Director – Investor Relations

Louise Romain
Investor Relation Manager

For more details, visit Foresight’s website here.

Morningstar Sustainalytics provides high-quality, analytical environmental, social and governance (ESG) research, ratings and data to institutional investors and companies.

For more than 30 years, our firm has focused on delivering innovative solutions that have enabled the world’s leading institutional investors to identify, understand, and manage ESG-driven risks and opportunities.

With Sustainalytics now a part of Morningstar, we’re accelerating our efforts to bring meaningful ESG insights to investors of all types across different asset classes at the company and fund level.

CONTACT

Natalia Fuentes
Client Relations Manager 

Caldon Pike
Client Relations Manager

For more details, visit Morningstar’s website here.