DC Savings Adequacy

Online in Zoom

Tuesday 5th March 2024

13:00 – 16:40 GMT

Getting to the Lightbulb Moment

The majority of people in private sector pension schemes have expectations for their pensions saving outcome which may be significantly greater than they are likely to achieve, even taking into account other savings and investments they may have, together with property income and the State Pension. The main problem is adequacy – simply having enough all round to fund a secure retirement.

Delegates to the Masterclass will explore what more can be done at a legislative level, at an employer level, at a pensions provider level, at an adviser level and at a member level to ensure that people save more. How do we trigger the lightbulb moment to witness a step change in individuals’ savings adequacy?

There will be a candid discussion on how this can be achieved, among more auto-enrolment legislation, more effective employment policies, better engagement and communication from technological and regulatory drivers, improved access to advice, and more robust data and information.

In common with all SGPE Masterclasses, the event will be highly interactive, with participants encouraged to engage and contribute proactively throughout.

Chair

David Porter

Chair – Master Trust Working Group
PASA

Keynote Speaker

Daniela Silcock

Head of Policy Research
Pensions Policy Institute

Agenda
Devil's Advocates

Rachel Brougham, Trustee Executive, BESTrustees
Fiona Brown, Group Head of Pensions, Rolls-Royce
Sofia Perkonigg, Trustee Director, UBS Pension Scheme

A panel of Devil’s Advocates will be on duty for the course of the afternoon.

They will be available to pose challenging questions to any of the conference speakers when invited to do so by the Moderator of each session. They will provide an end of day summary of the main learning and action points from the conference.

13.00 – 13.15
Meet & Greet
13.15 – 13.30
Welcome & Introduction

Masterclass Chair:
David Porter
Chair – Master Trust Working Group
PASA

Programme Director:
Stephen Glover
Director
SG Pensions Enterprise

13.30 – 13.55
Keynote Presentation: The Big Picture on UK Workplace Pensions Saving

Daniela Silcock
Head of Policy Research
Pensions Policy Institute

Our speaker will set the scene for the Masterclass with an examination of the overall state of retirement savings in the UK. She will seek to define what constitutes an adequate retirement income as that, for example, outlined as a desirable outcome by the PLSA or what others call the replacement ratio – the size of the typical shortfall after the State Pension and other pensions and personal savings are combined.

In doing this, she will discuss aggregate sources of saving and especially the role that DC workplace pensions play within them: an analysis of contribution rates, average pot size, average number of pots, variances by sector, by employer type, and other key metrics. The effect of a 5-year delay in raising auto enrolment contributions will be explored, and whether this suggests an urgent need to act on mandatory contribution increases to bridge the existing retirement wealth gap.

13.55 – 14.35
Panel Discussion: Confronting the Adequacy & Affordability Problem – Who is Doing What?

Moderator:
David Porter
Chair – Master Trust Working Group
PASA

Dominic Byrne
Head of DC Strategy EMEA

BlackRock

John Chilman
Chief Executive
Railpen

Anish Rav
Director of Pension Policy

Capita Pension Solutions

Eve Read
Senior Director of Strategic Delivery
Smart Pension

For pensions adequacy to be achieved, contribution rates into DC schemes must both increase and begin earlier in employees’ careers.

Our panel will discuss the practicalities of how this can be brought about. While a highly supportive regulatory framework, further provider consolidation, improved VFM and guardrails in place to protect retirement income are all important, ultimately it is savings levels that are the main determinant of an adequate pension. So, who needs to do what?

The main candidates are: more government legislation to raise auto-enrolment contributions, employer initiatives, manager and consultant strategies, pension provider initiatives, pot consolidation and employee education (the lightbulb). What are the likely keys to success and who will bear the cost of failure? Meantime, the most oft-heard response from individuals encouraged to save more is “I can’t afford to”.

Speakers will explore the truth of that statement, and discuss some of the initiatives that have sought to overcome this objection. Do we need to move away from political manoeuvring and declare that this is the hard choice the patient can’t make?

14.35 – 14.50
Coffee Break & Online Networking
14.50 – 14.55
A Quickfire Lesson on Dashboards & Adequacy

Richard Smith
Pensions Professional

Independent

14.55 – 15.35
Panel Discussion: How to Build A Workplace Savings Habit

Mark Hewitson
Head of Client Development
Wealth at Work

David Hutchins
Lead Portfolio Manager – Multi Asset Solutions

Alliance Bernstein

Liz Jewkes
Head of Pensions

Saint-Gobain UK & Ireland

Our speakers will explore the characteristics of the successful initiatives that have been undertaken by some employers to encourage employees to save more into pensions.

They will give their practical insights into what works and what doesn’t – with examples of the strategies and incentives that caused employees to raise contribution rates into the pension scheme or otherwise increase their savings – and whether they can genuinely move the needle on adequacy.

Most importantly, they will debate how to widen the net and encourage more employers to take up similar initiatives.

15.35 – 16.15
Expert Discussion Groups
Group 1) Policymaking & Governance

(Legislators, Trustees, Regulators, Trade Bodies)

Facilitator: Tegs Harding, Trustee Director, Independent Governance Group

Lead Discussants:
Andrew Blair, Head of Automatic Enrolment & Nest Policy, Department for Work & Pensions
Andy Dickson, Workplace Pensions Professional, Independent 
Lydia Fearn, Partner, LCP
Rob Yuille, Head of Long-Term Savings Policy, Association of British Insurers

Discussion:
Creators, trustees and enforcers of law and regulations will discuss what more they need to do at the policy and statutory level to make a key step change improvement in future pensions adequacy. They will also debate what initiatives and products they would like to see from commercial providers, employers and advisers to maximise the impact of policy support. 

Themes:

  • Mandating raising minimum contributions.
  • Reducing the age for AE – while making saving more affordable.
  • Scrapping the lower earnings limit – how effective would this be?
  • Dashboards – mandating “screen time” accessibility.
  • Legislating to resolve the gender and minorities pensions gap.
Group 2) Provision & Implementation

(Pension providers, Insurers, Employers, Consultants, Investment Managers, Lawyers)

Facilitator: Sophia Singleton, Head of DC, XPS Pensions Group

Lead Discussants: 
Julie Richards, Group Director of Pensions, Walgreens Boots Alliance
Richard Smith, Pension ProfessionalIndependent
Janette Weir, Managing DirectorIgnition House

Discussion:
Providers, advisers, managers and safe-keepers of the UK’s savers’ money will discuss what more they need to do at the employer, employee and product design levels to make a key step change improvement in savings adequacy. They will also debate the main changes that policymakers and legislators need to make to ensure their efforts are successful. 

Themes:

  • Making auto escalation strategies more widespread.
  • The “screen time” impact of commercial dashboards.
  • How (and who is responsible?) to educate savers about the adequacy gap.
  • Developments in small pot consolidation – empowerment?
  • Harnessing housing assets, equity release, and the problem for “generation rent”.
16.15 – 16.25
Feedback from Discussion Leaders

The Facilitators will report back on the main points covered and the salient conclusions reached in their respective discussion groups.

16.25 – 16.35
Devil's Advocates' Summary

The Devil’s Advocates will offer their summary and main takeaways from the afternoon’s proceedings.

16.35 – 16.45
Final Thoughts & Closing Remarks
Speakers

Andrew Blair

Head of Automatic Enrolment & NEST Policy
DWP

Rachel Brougham

Trustee Executive
BESTrustees

Fiona Brown

Group Head of Pensions
Rolls-Royce

Dominic Byrne

Head of DC Strategy EMEA
BlackRock

John Chilman

Chief Executive Officer
Railpen

Andy Dickson

Workplace Pensions Individual
Independent

Tegs Harding

Trustee Executive
Independent Governance Group

Mark Hewiston

Head of Client Development
Wealth at Work

David Hutchins

Lead Portfolio Manager
AllianceBernstein

Sofia Perkonigg

Trustee Director
UBS Pension Scheme

Anish Rav

Director of Pension Policy
Capita Pension Solutions

Eve Read

Senior Director of Strategic Delivery
Smart Pension

Julie Richards

Group Director of Pensions
Walgreens Boots Alliance

Sophia Singleton

Head of DC
XPS Pensions Group

Richard Smith

Pensions Professional
Independent

Janette Weir

Managing Director
Ignition House

Rob Yuille

Head of Long-Term Savings Policy
ABI

Sponsors
Click on images for more information
Scroll to Top

Andrew Blair

DC Investment & Governance Lead
Department for Work & Pensions

Andrew is the Head of Defined Contribution Investment and Governance Policy at the Department for Work and Pensions. He leads for the Department on the topical issues of illiquid investments, DC market consolidation and wider value for money policy for occupational DC savers.

Andrew has worked for the Department for Work and Pensions for 3 years, previously working in its Climate Change and Responsible Investment team.

Rachel Brougham

Trustee Executive
BESTrustees

Rachel Brougham has worked in the pensions industry for more than 30 years. She joined BESTrustees in 2014 and currently works with a number of clients, covering both defined benefit and defined contribution schemes.

Since joining BESTrustees, Rachel’s appointments have included two master trust boards and two Independent Governance Committees of major UK pension providers, and the chairmanship of a number of defined benefit schemes. Her experience includes the development of the trustee boards, their structures and processes, including committees and appropriate reporting, and the development of robust risk management frameworks.

Rachel is used to working with and managing a number of advisers on any one scheme, expecting a collaborative and respectful working relationship between them. She is also used to working with in-house teams, ensuring that the trustee board receives the support it needs in carrying out its duties. Working with the schemes’ advisers, she has implemented TPR’s integrated risk management (IRM) approach to funding, investment and covenant work in her DB schemes to good effect, and is used to working with an overseas parent.

Rachel spent most of her career at Mercer providing actuarial, benefit, governance and DC consulting advice to clients. She remains an Associate Member of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries.

Fiona Brown

Group Head of Pensions
Rolls-Royce

Fiona is currently Group Head of Pensions & Benefits at Rolls-Royce Plc. Her role is a hands on one in the UK, with fiduciary and strategic responsibilities outside the UK. Fiona is also global lead on Financial Wellbeing strategies. Fiona has previously held in house Pensions and Reward lead roles at Thomas Cook Plc and Electricity North West.

Prior to her in-house roles, Fiona spent 14 years at the Big 4, in consultancy roles. Fiona’s passion is financial wellbeing, improving general numeracy skills and better supporting people in making effective short and long term financial decisions.

John Chilman

Chief Executive Officer
Railpen

John joined as Chief Executive Officer and an Executive Director of Railpen, in June 2019, having previously served for 12 years as a Director of the Railways Pension Scheme Trustee Company, and Chair for the last five years. John is also an Independent Trustee of the Nestle UK pension fund.

 John is a Chartered Accountant by qualification, and was previously Group Head of Pensions at National Grid. Prior to that John held senior financial, commercial and pension positions at a number of large companies, including Pricewaterhouse Coopers, South Western Electricity, Shell, HBOS and First Group.

David Hutchins

lead Portfolio Manager – multi asset solutions
AllianceBernstein

David Hutchins is a Senior Vice President and Head of AB’s Multi-Asset Solutions business in EMEA. He is responsible for the development and management of multi-asset portfolios for a range of clients.
 
Hutchins joined the firm in 2008 after spending two years at UBS Investment Bank, where he was responsible for devising and delivering innovative capital markets risk-management solutions for pension schemes.
 
Prior to that, he spent 13 years at Mercer, where he served as a European principal and scheme actuary, providing trustee and corporate advice to a range of UK pension funds and their sponsors. Hutchins holds a BSc in mathematics and a PGCE from the University of Bristol. He has chaired the Investment Management Association’s Defined Contribution Committee and formerly chaired the defined contribution industry working group for the UK government’s “defined ambition” project.
 
Hutchins is a Fellow of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries in London. 

Julie Richards

Group Director of Pensions
Walgreens Boots Alliance

Since 2012, Julie has been Director of Pensions at Walgreens Boots Alliance, with responsibility for the company’s pension and retirement policy. Her role includes monitoring market and regulatory requirements and supporting the business in ensuring appropriate funding mechanisms and governance arrangements are in place. In the UK, such arrangements include a large closed DB pension scheme and a large contract-based DC scheme, with accompanying AE obligations. 

Prior to joining WBA, Julie held similar roles in the UK with a number of multinational employers, some of which included a broader remit to include other benefit and reward elements as well as direct involvement in working with trustees and managing both DB and DC trust-based pension schemes. 

Sophia Singleton

Partner & Head of DC
XPS Pensions Group

Sophia joined XPS Pensions Group in June 2020 to lead their DC business, helping clients deliver top class DC services to their members. Prior to that, she led Aon’s DC Consulting business. Sophia has over 24 years’ experience in the UK pensions industry and advises corporates and trustees on a range of DC pension solutions, developing and delivering DC strategies that optimise scheme design, ensuring effective governance and improving member outcomes. She is a well-known industry and media commentator on DC market developments and feels passionately that we must tackle short-term financial resilience as well as deliver better long-term post-retirement products, if we’re going to help today’s workforce to retire with the security and lifestyle they want; she is regularly quoted in the press and presents on DC issues at industry events.

Janette Weir

Managing Director
Ignition House

Janette is one of the founding directors of Ignition House. She has more than twenty years research experience and brings a broad range of research and consultancy skills and experience from her previous roles. Janette is responsible for new business development and is Head of the Financial Services and Public Sector Practices. She started her career as an economist at the Department of Work and Pensions, where she spent five years advising ministers and policy makers. This gave her a solid grounding in research skills and an understanding of the public sector.

She moved to be Chief Economist at the Association of British Insurers to build detailed knowledge of the insurance sector. From there, she led a team of thirty analysts covering all aspects of Financial Services as Head of UK Financial Services Research at McKinsey and Company. She was part of a pan-European team, which gave an international flavour to her research skill set. She also worked in a small team for a year to develop and implement McKinsey’s knowledge management strategy.

As Director of the Financial and Public Sector Practice at IQ Research, she built a solid practice of bespoke and syndicated work for financial services companies, economics consultancies, regulators, and trade associations. Janette is a well-known industry expert on the life and pensions sector, and often writes articles for the trade press.

Rob Yuille

Head of Long Term Savings Policy
Association for British Insurers (ABI)

Rob is Head of Long-Term Savings Policy at the Association of British Insurers. Since joining in January 2012 he has led the ABI’s work on customers’ retirement choices, responding to pension freedoms, and policy and governance around pensions dashboards.

He now oversees long-term savings policy areas from automatic enrolment to social care, and from investment platforms to Defined Benefit pensions. He previously worked at the Money Advice Service, the FSA and in policy and public affairs roles in the voluntary and private sectors.

AllianceBernstein is a leading investment-management firm with $646 billion in client assets under management, as of 31 December 2022. With a unique combination of expertise across equities, fixed-income, alternatives and multi-asset strategies, we aim to deliver differentiated insights and distinctive solutions to advance investors’ success.

Across our global network, we’re fully invested in delivering better outcomes for our worldwide clients, including institutional, high-net-worth and retail investors.

By embracing innovation, we seek to address increasingly complex investing challenges and opportunities. And we pursue responsibility at all levels of the firm—from how we work and act to the solutions we design for clients.

CONTACT

David Hutchins
Portfolio Manager – Multi Asset Solutions

Michelle Inskip
Managing Director – Institutional Client Group

For more details, visit AllianceBernstein’s website here.

Blackrock’s purpose is to help more and more people experience financial well-being. As a fiduciary to investors and a leading provider of financial technology, we help millions of people build savings that serve them throughout their lives by making investing easier and more affordable.

CONTACT

James Rowe
Managing Director

For more information, visit Blackrock’s website here.

Capita Pension Solutions is one of the UK’s leading pension firms. We partner with clients to provide an unrivalled breadth of services across Pension Administration, Data Solutions, Software and Consulting. We’ve been looking after people’s pensions for nearly 50 years, across pension schemes of all shapes and sizes. Our broad range of services means we are perfectly positioned to support employers, whatever their challenge. Our teams use their experience, insight, expertise, and the latest technology to deliver personalised end to end solutions to meet all our clients’ pension needs. 

CONTACT

Jeanette Smith
Senior DC Pension Consultant

Jason Becker
Senior Investment Consultant

For more details, visit Capita’s website here.

Smart Pension is one of the largest workplace pension providers in the UK, offering a modern pension that will be net zero by 2040. Over 85,000 UK businesses trust us with their workplace pension scheme. We now look after more than £2.5 billion in retirement savings for over a million people.

We’ve achieved all this in a short eight years, which makes us one of the fastest-growing companies in the retirement savings market. And there’s no stopping us, we have big plans to continue to use our Keystone technology, innovation, and user experience to transform retirement, savings and financial wellbeing, across all generations.

CONTACT

Karen Dallas
Business Development Director

Naomi Miller
Business Development Manager

For more details, visit Smart Pension’s website here.

WEALTH at work is a leading financial wellbeing and retirement specialist – helping those in the workplace to improve their financial future.  

Established in 2005, we work with hundreds of organisations across both the private and public sector by offering financial education, guidance and regulated financial advice. 

Our financial education and guidance services are delivered on a bespoke basis and can be specifically designed to help the entire workforce make informed decisions about their finances to support their financial wellbeing, covering everything from debt and money management through to optimising employer sponsored benefits and retirement income options. 

This can be delivered face-to-face or online and utilises digital nudge technology to encourage employee engagement and participation. Support is also provided through the creation of digital content such as webcasts, animations and interactive tools including the Financial Healthcheck.  

All our interactions are measured and can be benchmarked against the industry standard to fully understand the impact.  

CONTACT

Mark Hewitson
Head of Client Development

Rhys Keeling
New Business Development Executive

For more details, visit Wealth at Work’ website here.

Morningstar Sustainalytics provides high-quality, analytical environmental, social and governance (ESG) research, ratings and data to institutional investors and companies.

For more than 30 years, our firm has focused on delivering innovative solutions that have enabled the world’s leading institutional investors to identify, understand, and manage ESG-driven risks and opportunities.

With Sustainalytics now a part of Morningstar, we’re accelerating our efforts to bring meaningful ESG insights to investors of all types across different asset classes at the company and fund level.

CONTACT

Natalia Fuentes
Client Relations Manager 

Caldon Pike
Client Relations Manager

For more details, visit Morningstar’s website here.