Will Pensions Consolidation Deliver Real Efficiencies?

Thursday 17th June 2021

13:30-18:00 BST

Online in Zoom

Tuesday 17th June 2021

13:30 – 18:00 BST

Sponsored By

Challenges for Master Trusts, LGPS Pools & DB Plans

Consolidation is the name of the game in UK pensions. In the DC space, employers are increasingly rolling their plans into master trusts, in pursuit of efficiency gains, scale economies and wider investment opportunity sets, and are strongly encouraged by the authorities to do so. Similar arguments pertain for DB plans, especially smaller ones, though the rush to consolidate is less pronounced to date. LGPS plans have already implemented asset pooling across the entire sector, of course, with the streamlining of administrative activities a possible next step.

Delegates to the Masterclass will examine the actual state of consolidation across the pensions industry, whether it is really delivering on its promises, and what further developments need to take place in order to deliver significant and measurable improvement to the health of the industry and to overall member outcomes.

Chair

Robert Branagh

Chief Executive Officer
London Pension Fund Authority

Agenda
13.30 13.50
Meet & Greet
13.50 14.00
Welcome & Introduction

Chair:
Robert Branagh
Chief Executive Officer
London Pension Fund Authority

Programme Director:
Stephen Glover
Director
SG Pensions Enterprise

14.00 14.25
Presentation & Q&A: The State of Consolidation Across the Pensions Industry

Magnus Spence
Managing Director
Distribution Insights
Broadridge

Hal La Thangue
Associate Director
Broadridge

Our speakers will set the scene with the historic context for consolidation in UK pensions. They will discuss the drivers of consolidation, among them the current low return environment, the increasing burdens of reporting and regulation and the demand for better services to members of pension schemes. This will be explored in relation to trends and projections for the 3 main pensions sectors in UK pensions: LGPS, private DB and DC schemes.

They will posit that there is a minimum level of AUM to achieve scale benefits, and discuss the significance of the emergence of new players in the pensions marketplace, including fiduciary managers, transition managers and master trusts.

14.25 15.05
Panel Discussion: The Big Consolidators Account for Themselves

Moderator:
Robert Branagh
Chief Executive Officer

London Pensions Fund Authority


Ashu Bhargava
Senior Actuary
Clara Pensions

Mike Weston
Chief Executive Officer
LGPS Central

Chris Hitchen
Investment Committee Chair
NEST Corporation

Senior executives of three large consolidators, representing an LGPS Pool, a Master Trust and a DB consolidator, will describe and justify their approaches to consolidation, and how well they are working. The themes they will explore will include the correlation between size and investment performance; the governance challenges imposed by scale and how to manage them; whether consolidation is necessarily better for members; the pitfalls and drawbacks of rapid growth; and the optimal limits of consolidation on an industry-wide basis.

15.05 15.25
Sponsored Presentation:
Best Practice in Transitioning Assets

Graham Dixon
Director of Transitions
Inalytics

As consolidation trends develop further across UK pensions, this will translate into an enormous volume of assets on the move between funds, between institutions and into new investment vehicles. The importance of managing this process efficiently can hardly be exaggerated, given the great costs involved and the need to mitigate significant out-of-market and operational risks.

Our speaker will discuss how best practice in transition management is evolving in light of these circumstances and the steps involved in getting this critical process right, including the vital criteria for identifying the right transition manager.

15.25 15.45
Coffee at Home & Online Networking
15.45 16.05
Sponsored Presentation - A Special Case:
The DC Small Pots Problem

Adrian Boulding
Director of Policy
NOW: Pensions

It is well documented that the proliferation of small pensions savings pots will continue to grow almost exponentially if left unchecked. This gives rise to a huge administrative burden, rendering many pots totally uneconomic, both to the saver as well as to the pensions provider. Various solutions have been proposed, among them raising the bar on flat rates; transforming the general levy; nudges and pushes to members to consolidate their pots; legislative measures; and various technological solutions, not least the pensions dashboard.

Our presenter will outline the scale of the problem and propose a personal view of the best way to resolve it.

16.10 16.50
Expert Discussion Groups
Group 1: Predator or Prey? - Consolidating Smaller DB & DC Schemes

Facilitator:
Henry Tapper
Founder & CEO
AgeWage

Lead Discussants:
Andrew Blair
DC Investment & Governance Lead
Department for Work & Pensions

Paul Budgen
Director of Business Development
Smart Pension

Louise Sivyer
Policy Business Lead
The Pensions Regulator

Themes:

  • Savings to employers
  • Improved contributions to members
  • Wider investment opportunity sets
  • Exorbitant costs per member for small scheme administration
  • Barriers to consolidation 
  • Why even big schemes could shed a bit of weight

 

Group 2: Next Steps for LGPS Pooling

Facilitator:
Mike Weston
Chief Executive Officer
LGPS Central

Lead Discussants:
Abigail Leech
Finance Director
LPP Administration


Anthony Parnell
Treasury & Pension Investment Manager
Carmarthenshire County Council

David Rae
Head of Strategic Client Solutions
Russell Investments

Themes:

  • Achievements to date on asset pooling – is it working?
  • The LPP model: consolidating admin activities as well as assets
  • Lessons from overseas public schemes
  • Future legislation and outlook
16.55 17.00
Return to Plenary & Feedback from Expert Discussions
17.00 17.30
Panel Discussion: Tying It All Together

Moderator:
Robert Branagh
Chief Executive Officer
London Pensions Fund Authority

Henry Tapper
Founder & Chief Executive Officer
Stanford University

Mike Weston
Chief Executive Officer
LGPS Central

Discussion group facilitators will report back on their main conclusions, followed by a debate on the main takeaways and action points from the conference this afternoon. This will include who will be the significant winners and losers of consolidation trends, the further step changes that will need to take place and, as a consequence, what the future pensions landscape will look like.

17.30 18.00
Final Thoughts & Open Networking
Speakers

Ashu Bhargava

Senior Actuary

Clara Pensions

Andrew Blair

DC Investment & Governance Lead
Department for Work & Pensions

Adrian Boulding

Director of Policy

NOW: Pensions

Paul Budgen

Director of Business Management
Smart Pension

Graham Dixon

Director of Transitions
Inalytics

Chris Hitchen

Investment Committee Chair
NEST Corporation

Hal La Thangue

Associate Director
Broadridge

Abigail Leech

Finance Director
Local Pensions Partnership

Anthony Parnell

Treasury & Pensions Investment Manager
Carmarthenshire County Council

David Rae

David Rae

Head of Strategic Client Solutions

Russell Investments

Louise Sivyer

Policy Business
Lead


The Pensions Regulator

Magnus Spence

Managing Director
Distribution Insights


Broadridge

Henry Tapper

Founder & CEO
AgeWage

Mike Weston

Chief Executive Officer
LGPS Central

Sponsors
Click on images for more information
Scroll to Top

Robert Branagh

Chief Executive Officer
London Pensions Fund Authority

Robert is a pensions professional with an extensive business background. He has worked for trustee, not for profit, private equity owned, and insurance businesses over the last 30 years. Robert transitioned the Office of the Paymaster General from a public to a private sector outsourcing business in the late 1990’s and worked with Cabinet Office to establish the joint venture which became MyCSP. He has also managed the back office or pension functions for several pension schemes, including the NHS, Civil Service, Royal Mail Statutory scheme, and the £20 billion Railways pension scheme. Currently, he is the Chair of the Armed Forces Pension Scheme, a Governor of the Pensions Policy Institute and sits on the Board of Local Pensions Partnership Administration (LPPA), a fully-owned subsidiary of Local Pensions Partnership (LPP).

Robert is a regular speaker at pensions and employee benefits events and is a regular contributor to the UK pensions industry press. He is passionate about ensuring that members and employers at LPFA obtain the best support and service in an increasingly challenging pensions environment. At the LPFA, Robert’s focus is to provide support and quality service to members and employers, to support the development of and oversee LPP activities, to help the LPFA Board fulfil its statutory objectives and to work with interested stakeholders to ensure LPFA is an efficient, sustainable and well-run pension fund.

Ashu Bhargava

Senior Actuary
Clara Pensions

Ashu has worked with many boards of trustees and sponsors of pensions schemes on optimising their journey plans to self-sufficiency or buyout. Ashu joined Clara as he believes Clara takes innovative journey plan optimisation to another level and can provide even greater security for members and even greater certainty for sponsors, all at a lower cost. 

Ashu has 25 years’ experience in the pensions market, including at WTW, where he worked as both a Scheme and Corporate Actuary. While at WTW, a project led by Ashu won the Professional Pensions Pension Scheme Trustees of the Year Award and Pension Age Best Risk Management Exercise Award. While at L&G, a project led by Ashu won the Pension Age Best Risk Management Exercise Award. 

Andrew Blair

DC Investment & Governance Lead
Department for Work & Pensions

Andrew is the Head of Defined Contribution Investment and Governance Policy at the Department for Work and Pensions. He leads for the Department on the topical issues of illiquid investments, DC market consolidation and wider value for money policy for occupational DC savers.

Andrew has worked for the Department for Work and Pensions for 3 years, previously working in its Climate Change and Responsible Investment team.

Adrian Boulding

Director of Policy
NOW: Pensions

Adrian leads the Public Affairs team at NOW: Pensions, the UK’s third largest master trust. He has wide experience across the UK pensions landscape, having been actuary, administrator and trustee at both DB and DC schemes.

He is often to be found “in the thick of it” and was a member of Alistair Darling’s Stakeholder Advisory Group in 2001, of Steve Webb’s Making Auto-Enrolment Work Review in 2010 and of Guy Opperman’s Small Pots Working Group in 2020.

Adrian has published many articles and two books on pensions, Simply Secure and The Economics of the Coming Retirement Spaceship.

Paul Budgen

Director of Business Development
Smart Pension

Paul has worked at Smart Pension for 3 years and has over 25 years’ experience with leading UK providers of workplace pension schemes. He regularly contributes to debates, blogs and presents key insights to industry professionals, and is a member of the Chartered Insurance Institute, a mentor for the PMI and volunteers for the Pension Ombudsman.

Chris Hitchen

Chair – Investment Committee
Nest Corporation

Chris was one of the inaugural Trustees at Nest, a 9 million member DC scheme, and returned to its Board in 2018, where he chairs the Investment Committee. Chris is also Chair of the Border to Coast Pensions Partnership, a pooling vehicle set up by twelve LGPS pension funds with assets of over £40 billion. In addition, he is corporate Chair at the Pension SuperFund, an initiative to consolidate private sector DB pension schemes.

Chris is a Board member for the Toronto-based International Centre for Pensions Management, and for the UK’s Investor Forum, a conduit for strategic dialogue between companies and investors, and an outcome of the Kay Review, on which Chris served.

Chris is an Actuary, a Past Chair of the Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association and an Honorary Fellow of the CFA Society of the UK. He and his wife Pip have four mostly grown-up sons and in his spare time, Chris runs marathons slowly.

Hal La Thangue

Associate Director
Broadridge

Hal is an Associate Director within the Distribution Insight team at Broadridge. He is responsible for using insights generated by Broadridge’s unique datasets to advise asset managers on key opportunities across the world’s retail and institutional market, with a primary focus on EMEA.

Hal is a key contributor to Broadridge’s work on UK DB and DC pensions, and retirement income. He also leads research into various product segments, the various strands of factor investing being an area of particular expertise.

He holds an MSc Economics from LSE and taught introductory economics to undergraduates at the university.

Abigail Leech

Finance Director
Local Pensions Partnership

Abigail has been the Finance Director for the Local Pension Partnership (LPP) Administration business since November 2020. Prior to joining LPP, she was the Head of Lancashire County Pension Fund for 6 years and the interim S151 officer for the London Pension Fund Authority (LPFA). 

 Abigail’s background within the Council is varied having recent experience in the governance and oversight arrangements for the Pension Fund and its shareholder relationship with LPP. Before joining Lancashire County Council, she worked as a Corporate tax manager for Deloitte and an external auditor for a local Manchester accountancy firm where she qualified as a chartered accountant and chartered tax advisor.

Anthony Parnell

Treasury & Finance
Business Manager
Carmarthenshire County Council

Anthony has been the Treasury and Pension Investments Manager for Carmarthenshire County Council (host authority of the Wales Pension Partnership (WPP)) since February 2007. He is a qualified ACCA accountant and manages the Treasury Management, Banking and Technical Accountancy services of the Council and the Fund Investments, Accounting and Governance of the £3bn Dyfed Pension Fund. He attends all relevant pooling events on behalf of the WPP. 

He has worked in financial services his entire career including Redbridge Health Authority, Inner London Probation Service, Dyfed County Council and Pembrokeshire County Council. He is treasurer of Carmarthen Town AFC, a qualified workplace coach and a keen cyclist, raising thousands of pounds for charitable organisations.

David Rae

David Rae

Head of Strategic Client Solutions
Russell Investments

David is Head of Strategic Client Solutions at Russell Investments. Based in London, he leads the team responsible for developing investors’ portfolio strategies in light of their specific circumstances. David works with pension fund, insurance, and other clients across EMEA to build portfolio solutions to manage risks, including liability hedging, and generate the required level of returns.

Louise Sivyer

Policy Business Lead
The Pensions Regulator

Louise is a policy principal in TPR’s Regulatory Policy Directorate. She joined the Regulator in 2007, and has worked in both policy and operational teams, across issues relating to both DB and DC.  

 Louise leads the team responsible for developing policy relating to the Governance and Administration of trust-based pension schemes. This includes the ‘Future of Trusteeship’ initiative, Pensions Dashboards and the regulation of DC schemes.  

 Before joining the Regulator, Louise spent 12 years working in the pensions industry in technical roles ranging across the pension mis-selling review, third party pension administration, and TPAS (The Pensions Advisory Service). 

Magnus Spence

Managing Director
Distribution Insight
Broadridge

Magnus has provided data and research to asset management clients to help address distribution-related challenges since 1994. In 2008, he co-founded Spence Johnson to concentrate on providing data-based research services to institutional asset managers and insurers. In 2017, Spence Johnson was acquired by Broadridge and he is now helping to build Broadridge’s Global Distribution Solutions consulting capabilities from London.

Henry Tapper

Founder & CEO
AgeWage

Henry is the founder of both AgeWage and the Pension PlayPen, designed to map the pensions genome and ensure everyone gets data driven information on value for money. He has worked most of his career in pensions, most recently as a Director of First Actuarial, and notably at Eagle Star and Zurich Assurance.

He is a well known blogger on all pensions-related issues at henrytapper.com.

Mike Weston

Chief Executive Officer
LGPS Central Ltd.

Mike was appointed Chief Executive Officer of LGPS Central Ltd. in March 2019. He was previously Chief Executive of the Pensions Infrastructure Platform (PiP). Mike had been Chief Investment Officer for the DMGT pension schemes and worked as an Investment Director in the City managing institutional equity portfolios at asset management firms such as Hermes and Merrill Lynch Investment Managers.

In 2013, Mike was appointed as an Independent Trustee of the Institute of Cancer Research Pension Scheme. He has also served as a Non-Executive Director of the NAPF and as Vice Chair of its Defined Benefit Council.

Mike holds an MBA from Cranfield School of Management and graduated from Cambridge University with an MA in Natural Sciences.

AgeWage is a fintech company that helps fiduciaries, sponsors and DC pension savers understand the value they are getting for their money. We analyse data in individual saver’s contribution histories and present individualised performance as a score, benchmarked against the average performance measured by a Morningstar benchmark.

Our work is useful for IGCs, GAAs and Trustees looking to compare schemes for Value for Money and we have attracted the interest of the Government for our innovative thinking and our capacity to analyse data in bulk. To date, AgeWage has analysed more than 2.5m individual pots.

CONTACT

Rahul Agarwal
Chief Operating Officer

Aron Maus
Commercial Director

For more details, visit AgeWage’s website here.

Clara Pensions is the member-first consolidator for defined benefit pension schemes. It acts as a bridge for pension scheme members, from the company that currently supports their pension to a long-term insured future.

Clara provides a safer pension promise today by combining its own capital and robust governance with additional contributions from sponsors, who can now transfer the burden of their pension liabilities to Clara. This frees up companies to focus on their future growth.

Clara will provide a low-risk journey to an insured buyout, giving members the security of a fully insured pension earlier. Only once all members have their full benefits secured will Clara provide a long-term return on capital for investors.

We are currently being assessed by The Pensions Regulator against their specific Guidance for ‘Superfunds’ and look forward to undertaking transactions.

CONTACT

Richard Williams
Director of Policy & Communications

For more details, visit Clara’s website here.

The Inalytics Transitions Services team brings with them a wealth of experience, advising on over £200B of transitions since 2015, with clients including pensions, sovereign wealth funds, wealth management companies and insurance companies. We provide guidance at every stage of a transition:

  • Before: Independent, empirical scrutiny of potential transition managers’ proposals to help you understand their implementation strategy. We critically assess their previously completed transitions to reveal their level of skill.

  • During: Expert monitoring during the transitions event to ensure that any potential disruptions to completion are quickly identified and mitigated.

  • After: Clear and objective reporting which verifies the implementation shortfall and provides a critical assessment of the transition manager’s performance.

Clients have used our bespoke analysis and reporting to avoid common pitfalls, hold transitions managers to account for their decisions, and occasionally to recover fees.

CONTACT

David Edgar
Director – Transitions

Neil Miller
Assistant Director – Transitions

For more details, visit Inalytics’ website here.

NOW: Pensions is an award-winning UK workplace pension provider. We look after the pension savings of tens of thousands of employers and millions of members from a wide range of industry sectors.

We have a clear mission – to help everyone save for a more financially secure future. This means achieving the best financial outcomes for our own members, while fighting for a fair pension system to enable all pension savers to enjoy the retirement they deserve. We do this by highlighting pension inequalities and campaigning for change.

We are the UK’s third largest auto enrolment pension provider by number of members.

NOW: Pensions is part of the Cardano Group, a market leader in providing risk and investment management services designed to make pensions outcomes more stable and robust.

CONTACT

For more details, visit NOW: Pensions’ website here.

Russell Investments is a leading global investment solutions partner, dedicated to improving people’s financial security. We offer actively managed multi-asset portfolios and services that include advice, investments and implementation.

We have £236.39 billion* in Assets Under Management and works with over 1,800 clients globally, independent distribution partners and individual investors in 32 countries globally. As a consultant to some of the world’s largest pools of capital, we have £2 trillion** in Assets Under Advice, Assets traded around £2 trillion and managed 197 transition events representing£66 billion through its Implementation Services business.

*AUM as of 31/03/21
**AUA as of 30/06/20
All other data as of 31/12/20.

CONTACT

Caroline Tsalos
UK Institutional Director

Gary Yeaman
UK Institutional Director

For more details, visit Russell Investments’ website here.

Smart Pension is one of the UK’s largest providers of DC workplace pensions – helping hundreds of thousands of UK workers save for retirement.

Founded in 2014, Smart Pension was created to modernise the retirement industry in the UK. Now, they’re enhancing their multiple award-winning master trust to be the best choice for every employer. They take a different approach to traditional pensions by putting their customers first and their purpose-built platform makes saving easy and secure for their members.

They’ve received investments from global financial giants including J.P. Morgan, Barclays, Natixis, Link Group and Legal & General Investment Management.

CONTACT

Karen Dallas
Business Development Director

Naomi Miller
Business Development Manager

For more details, visit Smart Pension’s website here.

Morningstar Sustainalytics provides high-quality, analytical environmental, social and governance (ESG) research, ratings and data to institutional investors and companies.

For more than 30 years, our firm has focused on delivering innovative solutions that have enabled the world’s leading institutional investors to identify, understand, and manage ESG-driven risks and opportunities.

With Sustainalytics now a part of Morningstar, we’re accelerating our efforts to bring meaningful ESG insights to investors of all types across different asset classes at the company and fund level.

CONTACT

Natalia Fuentes
Client Relations Manager 

Caldon Pike
Client Relations Manager

For more details, visit Morningstar’s website here.